Guide

AI SEO services One phrase, two opposite purchases

An AI SEO agency is either selling you AI as a way to produce SEO work, or selling you visibility inside AI engines. Those are different products with similar proposals, and the words do not tell you which.

Check your site for free

The split that decides everything else

Every other question about an AI SEO engagement depends on this one, and it is almost never asked directly, because the phrase does not force anyone to answer it.

AI as the method
Models write the content, fill the metadata, cluster the keywords and build the internal links. What is being sold is the same SEO work, produced faster and at a lower price than people can produce it. The deliverable is volume.
AI as the audience
The site is changed so that ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google’s AI answers can reach it, parse it and quote it correctly. What is being sold is being present in answers you currently do not appear in. The deliverable is a change in what engines say about you.

Both are legitimate. Neither is what the other one is. A company that needed the second and bought the first ends up with several hundred new pages and the same absence from every answer engine, which is an expensive way to find out what the phrase meant on the invoice.

What to ask before anyone quotes

Five questions, in this order. The first two sort which product is being offered and the rest only matter once that is settled.

  1. Which of the two are you selling me? If the answer is both, ask what proportion of the hours goes to each, and expect a number.
  2. How will I see that it worked, without logging into your tool? Crawler access, markup validity and what an engine says about us cold are all checkable from outside. Rankings inside a dashboard are not.
  3. What is generated and what is written? Not a trick question and not a reason to walk away. An agency that cannot answer it precisely is telling you they do not track it.
  4. Who signs off on accuracy? Generated pages about a subject nobody internally understands are the single most common way this work damages a brand.
  5. What happens to the work if we stop? Changes made to your own site stay yours. Anything that evaporates when the retainer ends was a subscription wearing a project’s clothes.

What you can settle yourself first

The visibility half starts with a short, specific list, and knowing which items are already failing changes the conversation with anyone you hire. It also changes the price, because a proposal written against a known starting point is a different document from one written against a guess.

The free check on this site reads one page the way an engine would and reports which of those items pass. It takes under a minute, and the ranked fix list it produces is the brief you would otherwise be paying somebody to write.

Questions about AI SEO services

Does an AI SEO agency use AI, or get you found by AI?

Ask, because it is genuinely both in the market and almost never both in one contract. Using AI means they produce your content and metadata with models, faster and cheaper than writers. Being found by AI means they change the site so engines can read and quote it. The first is a production method, the second is an outcome, and a proposal that does not say which is on offer is worth sending back.

What should an AI SEO engagement deliver?

Something you can check without them. For the production kind, that is published work you can read and a record of what was generated against what was edited. For the visibility kind, it is a before and after on things that can be measured from outside: crawler access, valid markup, what a model says about you when asked cold. Anything whose only evidence is their own dashboard is not a deliverable.

Is automated SEO worth paying for?

For the mechanical parts, often yes. Missing metadata, broken internal links, alt text and schema across thousands of pages are exactly what automation is for, and doing them by hand is a poor use of anyone. The risk is in the judgement parts. Automated content at scale is what every engine has spent two years learning to discount, and a site can be made measurably worse by filling it with pages nobody asked for.

Can AI write SEO content that ranks?

It can, and the thing that decides it is not the writing tool. A model can produce a competent page on a topic you understand, which an expert then corrects and signs. The same model produces a plausible page on a topic nobody at the company understands, and that is the one that gets found out, by readers first and engines second. The question to ask of any generated page is who checked it and what they knew.

How do I check what an AI SEO agency actually did?

Pick things visible from outside the relationship. Fetch your own robots.txt and see which crawlers are allowed. Run your markup through a validator. Ask an engine what your company does and read the answer. Check Search Console for pages that appeared without anyone mentioning them. None of this needs their cooperation, which is the point.

Do I need an agency for this at all?

The readability half is mostly a short list of specific changes, and a developer who already has the codebase will do them faster than anyone you brief from scratch. Where outside help earns its place is scale, a long backlog across many templates, or an organisation that needs someone accountable for the work. Start by finding out which of those you have.

Find out what is already failing

Run the free check first. The fixes it ranks are the brief, and you can hand it to anyone.

Check your site for free